Director: John
August
Released: 2007
Starring: Ryan
Reynolds, Melissa McCarthy, Hope Davis, Elle Fanning, David Denman,
Octavia Spencer, Ben Falcone, Dahlia Salem, John Gatins
Plot: A troubled
actor, a show runner and a videogame designer discover that their
lives might be more linked than they suspect.
Review: While John
August might not be a name which leaps out at you he has worked on
several noteworthy screenplays for the likes of “Titan A.E.”,
“Frankenweenie” and the cult indie movie “Go” which initially
launched him as a screenwriter with this film marking his directorial
debut with decidedly mixed results.
A three part
existential drama this pet project clearly has the
feel of someone trying to imitiate the experimental style of Charlie
Kaufman only with none of the quirky charm as here Ryan Reynolds
plays the three lead roles each heading up their own chapters
starting with “The Prisoner” which see actor Gary barbequing his
ex-girlfriends things before flipping his car and landing himself on
house arrest. Soon however he finds himself being being plagued by
the continual appearance of the number 9 around him.
Next up is “Reality
Television” which now sees Reynolds playing the Television writer
Gavin who is trying to get the pilot for his TV show “Knowing”
off the ground while being followed for a reality show. The whole
segment being shot in reality TV show style making for an interesting
change of pace and helping the segment to stand out along with
elements such as Melissa McCarthy’s role in this segment being to
play the fictionalised version of herself. This segment perhaps the
most autobiographical for August who based most of the plot on his
experience’s working on the failed television series “D.C.”
while he wrote the film with McCarthy in mind for her role, mirroring
Gavin’s own writing were he wrote his TV show for this reality’s
version of her.
The final segment is
“Knowing” were Reynolds now plays the acclaimed video game
designer Gabriel whose car has broken down in the middle of nowhere
with his wife Mary (McCarthy) and daughter which aims for the big
reveal of what has supposed to have been happening throughout the
film and bring all the parts together. Instead we get the feeling of
August self congratulating himself for what he’s created even
though its still very much feels like a half baked and largely
confusing mess.
Released before
Reynolds achieved the mainstream approval he got from “Deadpool”
and when many critics for some reason were keen to write him off like
Ben Affleck as box office poison a tag I never really understood for
either, especially Reynolds who might have come to the forefront
through throw away cult comedies like “Van Wilder” and “Waiting”
he’s constantly remained an intresting actor to watch especially
when given a more dramatic role like he got with “Adventureland”
or “Smokin Aces” and here he certainly gets that by getting to
play three different leads all three of which he manages to make
stand out from each other. This is certainly true in the case of “The
Prisoner” and “Reality TV” two characters which are at polar
opposite to each other with Gary coming across as bratty and self
indulgent compared to the self-doubting and moody Gavin its just more
frustrating that neither character ultimately get the interesting
arc’s that they deserve and instead are left in meandering
plotlines blogged down by August’s attempts to link all the
segments together and play into his end game.
The supporting cast
are equally great with both Melissa McCarthy and Hope Davis joining
Reynolds in playing multiple characters across the different stories
with mixed results due to the strength of the material rather than
either actresses performance.
While I might have
entered into the film with an expectation of what I was going to get
it was somewhat disapointing to ultimately end up with a plot so
plodding and ultimately navel gazing as the one that August chooses
to craft here, as a potentially interesting idea is squandered by his
attempts to really tie together three half baked stories that perhaps
would have been better developed on their own than stuck together
here.